Whether you’re a casual buyer or a long time collector, baseball cards can often hold a lot of value. So, if you have boxes of them stashed away in your attic or garage, you can probably make some quick money by selling them.
Before you part with your collectibles, uncover these 8 Genius Money Moves to Score $500+ in Free Cash This Week! Why sell when you can earn more effortlessly?
And the great news is that baseball cards are a very popular collectible. In fact, there’s over 12,000+ different sets and over a million cards in existence worldwide, some of which are worth a lot of money.
So, if you’re wondering how to sell baseball cards to make some extra cash, you’re in luck.
In this post, I’m covering some of the best places to sell baseball cards. I’m also including a combination of online marketplaces and local selling websites you can use so you have plenty of options.
Want even more fast money ideas besides selling cards? Checkout:
- EarnIn: Borrow up to $750 against an upcoming paycheck!
- National Debt Relief: Get fast debt relief if you have $10,000+ in debt!
Where To Sell Baseball Cards
When it comes to selling baseball cards for cash, or any type of sports card for that matter, it’s important to know where to find serious buyers so you don’t waste your time and actually get offers.
Thankfully, there are plenty of online marketplaces where you can start out. And if those fail, there’s also local selling options that you can use to get paid in cash.
1. eBay
This long time favorite marketplace for both buyers and sellers, eBay is an excellent place for almost anything collectible.
From classics like Disney VHS tapes and Beanie Babies to collectible cards like Yugioh cards and sports trading cards, the sales opportunities are enormous.
Baseball cards aren’t an exception, and there are thousands of active listings and sellers on the marketplace right now.
eBay is also useful since you can sell your entire collection or individual baseball cards if they’re rare enough.
Just make sure you know a little about the card(s) that you’re hoping to sell, including pricing that they’re actually selling for. Also include pictures with your listing and also list any pertinent info such as included documentation.
Also know that eBay charges seller fees of 12.9% for trading cards up to $7,500. Afterwards, you pay 2.35% in fees for the remaining balance.
This is a pretty steep seller fee. But the trade-off is that you can get your baseball cards in front of thousands of collectors from around the world for a potential quick sale.
2. Beckett
A top sports card collectible site, Beckett specializes in baseball cards, football cards, and basketball cards. And it’s also an excellent way to sell individual cards or entire collections.
To sell baseball cards through Beckett, you can start by listing your cards on its marketplace to try and find other buyers.
This is a pretty massive marketplace as well. At the time of writing, there’s over 128 million cards listed, and Beckett also works with 70+ professional card dealers.
Alternatively, you can sell your cards directly to Beckett, and the website also has excellent price guides to help you value your cards. And for very rare baseball cards, you can use Beckett’s grading service to get a professional grading and valuation.
The marketplace probably has eBay beat as well for the sheer number of sports card fans, so it’s an excellent starting place.
3. Dave & Adam’s
Another top marketplace to sell baseball cards is Dave & Adam’s. This popular website is known for trading cards and also specializes in hobby boxes, packs, and rare cards.
However, Dave & Adam’s has some requirements for the types of baseball cards you can sell.
For example, modern baseball cards need to be over $50 in value or be professionally graded. They also accept raw vintage baseball cards that are from 1970 or earlier.
To sell to Dave & Adam’s, you submit your card or collection for a quote. Once you get the offer, you can accept it if you’re happy with the price and then ship it to Dave & Adam’s. Large orders get free shipping, and you get paid with PayPal money after the company inspects your cards.
The lack of seller fees is one plus of selling baseball cards to Dave & Adam’s. And you can also opt for store credit if you’re interested in buying something else from the site.
4. Alt
Alt is a newer option for selling baseball cards, and it’s one of the best choices if you want to buy, sell, and manage your entire collection with an easy-to-use app.
With Alt, you can quickly sell individual cards or collections by listing on Alt’s marketplace. Alt also crosslists your cards on eBay, which is my favorite feature of the app.
Alt also lets you get instant cash for your cards if you sell them on its liquid auction. You get up to 60% of a card’s value this way. Alternatively, you can list baseball cards at a fixed-price and only pay a 5% seller fee.
I also like Alt since it provides suggestions for your listing price, name, and even which photos to use. Listing also takes no time at all since Alt’s app is quite beginner-friendly.
Plus, if you just want to manage your collection, you can add your cards digitally to Alt and track the value of your entire portfolio right from your phone.
5. Facebook Marketplace
If you’re still wondering where to sell baseball cards, one simple option you can try is the Facebook Marketplace.
This local selling site is an excellent way to find local buyers for just about anything. And you don’t have to deal with shipping or seller fees either.
Popular things to sell on Facebook Marketplace include things like apparel, furniture, electronics, and shoes. But more niche collectibles like baseball cards can also sell fast, especially if you live in a larger city.
However, Facebook is more than just a useful local selling site. And plenty of people in my area are selling baseball cards and other sports cards.
For example, you can find excellent groups with buyers and sellers for pretty much any niche or hobby. And there are plenty of Facebook groups with baseball fans where you can sell your cards.
These groups require more work on your end since it’s all peer-to-peer, so you’re not dealing with a business or card shop.
But you can find serious buyers, and also ask questions to the general groups if you need help learning how to grade, value, and sell your baseball cards.
6. Dean’s Cards
Another option for selling baseball cards online is to sell through Dean’s Cards. This vintage sports card site focuses on vintage cards, including baseball cards, from before 1978. If you have older or rare baseball cards, this card seller is a must visit.
Dean’s Cards have a best price guarantee, and you submit a request form that outlines your collection to get started.
From there, Dean’s Cards offers you a quote. If you accept, you ship your cards off and get paid via check once it can inspect your cards.
Note that rookie cards, star cards, and rare cards are mostly what Dean’s Cards is after. But the video above does an excellent job at outlining the selling process and requirement.
7. Just Collect
This NJ-based online auction house is one of the largest online retailers for sports memorabilia. In fact, Just Collect says that in its 60 years of hobby and cards experience, it’s purchased over $20 million from sellers!
Just Collect also works similarly to other stores that buy baseball cards. All you have to do is submit your collection online, get a quote, and decide if you want to sell or not.
This is a great option to get a free appraisal, and it’s also an easy way to sell an entire collection if you need fast cash. Plus, Just Collect pays for shipping and insurance.
And if you happen to live in New York or New Jersey, you can pass by the shop to sell your baseball cards in person.
8. Blowout Card Forums
Forums can be an excellent way to connect with others who have similar interests. And they’re often be a great place to buy and sell as well!
Blowout Card Forums isn’t an exception, and the baseball card section of the site has thousands of members and active posts every day.
You can learn about selling baseball cards, hockey cards, and other sports collectibles from other members. And people also post cards for sale all the time.
9. Reddit r/baseballcards
While it might surprise you, another one of the best places to sell baseball cards is Reddit’s r/baseballcards community.
With over 66,000 collectors, this is another very active community of baseball card fans. And there’s a monthly buy/sell/trade thread where you can sell your cards, add to your collection, or swap with others.
People also post their cards to show off for fun, and there’s new posts every day, so it’s a cool community even without the selling potential.
Just note that you have to deal with other Reddit users, so you have to negotiate and deal with shipping and payment with another person.
10. COMC
Another way to sell baseball cards online is to sell through COMC, or Check Out My Collectibles.
This online platform for trading cards specializes in those of very high value, with some cards going for well over $100,000. So, if you have some rare or vintage baseball cards in excellent condition that are also graded, this is the website for you.
COMC is by far the best choice to sell valuable old baseball cards. And with processing fees as low as $0.50-$2.00 for each card, and no shipping fees for sellers, the costs are very low.
This baseball card resale website also has great guides, tools and other resources to help you estimate the value of your cards.
11. Hobby & Collector Shops
If you want to sell baseball cards locally, going to a hobby and collector shop is one of your best bets. This is true for any collectible really, including things like sports cards, Funko Pops, and Pokemon cards.
Just note that since hobby shops are in the business to resell for a profit, the prices they offer for your cards may not be as high as what you could receive elsewhere.
However, they do the selling work for you and it can be an easier option, especially if you need cash fast.
Shops may only buy cards and collections during certain hours when their buyer or resident expert is in-house. It can help to make a call ahead of your trip to see if they are available to review your cards and to make an offer.
That said, there’s a lot of potential to flip your money here if you know what you’re doing.
For example, my teen has been picking up card sets at local thrift sales and discount stores and then reselling them to local collector shops for double and triple what he paid for them. It has been an easy way for him to earn extra cash, without having to have much money to invest.
12. Swap Meets, Flea Markets & Local Events
Trying to sell a large baseball card collection? It might be worth setting up a booth at a local card show or even a flea market.
While this costs money since you normally have to rent a booth and table, this can be an excellent way to find a lot of local buyers in just a few hours.
And if you enjoy chatting with others and learning more about this hobby and the cards you own, this can be an enjoyable as well as a profitable experience.
13. Auction House
Have a particularly valuable baseball card or collection? In this case, you might be able to sell it for top dollar with assistance from a local auction house.
For example, a particularly rare Mickey Mantle card recently sold for a whopping $12.8 million dollars! This just goes to show you what kind of money there is in trading cards.
However, not every baseball card or collection is going to be auction worthy. This outlet is meant more for antique and mint-condition, high end items that are professionally graded.
Also note that selling through an auction house can be a slower process. However, it can help you reach collectors who can afford higher end items. If a sale is made, you will pay the auction house a commission which could vary between 10 and 50%.
14. SportsCardPro
If you have some vintage baseball cards for sale, one website you can use is SportsCardPro.
I like SportsCardPro since it lets you add your baseball cards to your account to track the value of your collection. Plus, it has useful data on various baseball card sets and their current market value depending on the year and condition of the cards.
If you live in the United States or Canada, you can also use SportsCardPro to sell baseball cards online.
Listing is completely free, and buyers contact you to ask questions or make a sale. You transact with PayPal, and there aren’t any final sale fees, minus potential PayPal fees.
The site also supports other types of sports cards, and again, its collection value tracking tool is pretty useful!
15. Craigslist
One final place to sell baseball cards is Craigslist, a popular classifieds website.
Like Facebook Marketplace, Craigslist lets you post things you have for local sale. It’s a very popular way to sell things like old furniture, appliances, clothing, but also more niche collectibles.
Baseball card collections pop up on Craigslist sometimes, especially if you search in larger cities.
Listing is also completely free, so it’s a pretty risk-free way to sell your cards. And getting paid in cash from local buyers is a plus.
Extra Reading – Craigslist vs Facebook Marketplace For Sellers.
What Makes Baseball Cards Valuable?
Determining your baseball card collection’s value is the most important step in selling. This is because many cards aren’t worth much, so you want to be sure your cards are actually worth something before you spend any time looking for buyers.
Now, there are many factors that influence baseball card prices. One of the main ones is the card era.
According to Dean’s Cards, there are four main eras for baseball cards, with Pre-War and Vintage cards typically being more valuable than newer cards:
- Pre-War Baseball Cards (1860s – WWII)
- Vintage Baseball Cards (1948 – 1969)
- Semi-Vintage Baseball Cards (1970s)
- Modern Baseball Cards (1980s – Present Day)
Other factors that influence baseball card prices include condition, if you have a professional grade or not, and if the card is a rookie, star, or rare card.
This video from Dean’s Cards provides an excellent overview of how to grade your baseball cards.
You can learn this process yourself. Then, by cross-referencing prices on eBay and other marketplaces, you should get a general idea of how much your baseball cards are worth.
Tips For Selling Your Baseball Cards
Now that you know some of the best places to sell baseball cards and how to value your collection, here are a few final tips to make the process a bit easier:
- Stay Organized: Organization is key to keeping track of your collection’s value, sales, and negotiations with buyers. I suggest making a spreadsheet with all your cards so you don’t lose track of any data.
- Research Other Sellers: Reference what other sellers are pricing their cards at so you have a bit of a benchmark for yours.
- Shop Around: If you don’t need money right now, you can afford to shop around a few places to try and get the best price for your cards.
- Know Your Lowest Price: When selling stuff, always know the absolute lowest price you’ll accept. This ensures you know when to walk away so you don’t accept a lowball offer.
Extra Reading – How To Earn Money Using Your Home.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who Buys Baseball Cards Near Me?
The most popular way to sell baseball cards locally is to use pawn shops or local antique shops. Alternatively, you can list your collection on local selling marketplaces like Facebook Marketplace or Craigslist.
Local sales are ideal since you can get paid in cash and avoid shipping and online payment processing fees. However, you might be able to get more for you baseball cards online since you have a larger pool of potential buyers.
What’s The Best Online Option?
Websites the specialize in buying and selling old baseball cards like Beckett and Just Collect are probably your best online option. However, auction sites like eBay can also be effective, especially if you have rare cards that generate a lot of interest and bidding.
Final Thoughts
If you’re looking for the best place to sell baseball cards, the truth is there are lots of options! Collector cards are a hot commodity, and if you want to make money online or in person, you’re not alone.
Whether you sell through marketplaces like Facebook or eBay, using a collector site, or working with professional buyers, selling baseball cards can be a profitable hobby.
Just make sure to take good care of your collection and to know the values before you get ready to sell. Research really is key, and the time you spend valuing your collection all benefits you when you actually make a sale.
Looking for even more selling side hustles? Checkout:
- The Best Things To Buy In Bulk & Resell Individually.
- The Best Places To Sell Used Bikes.
- Where To Sell Board Games For Cash.
