Every serious hockey fan has their own way of passionately supporting their favorite teams and players.
Hockey cards are one of the most common and collectible displays of devotion. And whether you love vintage cards or ones of current players, a nice set of hockey cards in good condition is certainly a nice way to connect to the game.
Plus, the right hockey cards can also be worth a lot of money. So, if you need quick cash and want to declutter your home a bit, you’re in luck.
In this post, I’m covering some of the best places to sell hockey cards that you can use to turn that old collection of yours into some side cash.
Looking for other money-making ideas? Checkout:
- Branded Surveys: Share your opinion to get PayPal cash and gift cards!
- Freecash: A fun way to earn gift cards and cash prizes online.
Where To Sell Hockey Cards
Despite being a niche market, there are a multitude of ways to make real money online or in person by selling hockey cards.
My personal preference is to use a combination of local selling sites and online marketplaces so you reach the most buyers. Below, you’ll find plenty of online and local selling options, so pick a few and then get ready to sell your hockey cards for cash!
1. Dean’s Cards
One of the most popular places to sell hockey cards you can consider is Dean’s Cards.
This sports card dealer buys and sells a variety of sports cards, including baseball cards, hockey cards, football cards, and even sports magazines.
You can submit your hockey cards for sale using this link. Currently, you can sell hockey cards that are pre-1978, pre-1985 complete sets, and pre-1975 graded hockey cards.
Once you submit your cards for sale, Dean’s Cards offers you a quote. If you accept the quote, you ship off your cards or collection to Dean’s Cards and then get paid in cash after the company reviews and accepts your cards.
- Best For: Selling rare cards, rookie cards, star cards.
- Pros: Has some of the highest premiums for high-value cards.
- Cons: Doesn’t always accept common, less valuable cards.
2. Facebook Marketplace
The Facebook Marketplace is the backbone of a huge volume of local transactions all over the world. So naturally, it’s one of the best places to sell hockey cards locally and to buyers outside of your immediate area.
I’ve sold plenty of things on Facebook Marketplace before, ranging from MTG cards and old furniture to guitars.
The main advantage of Facebook Marketplace is that you deal in cash and don’t have to worry about shipping your collectibles. You don’t pay any online sales fees either.
It’s actually a super simple process. All you need to do is log into your Facebook account, create a listing for your hockey cards on the Marketplace, and start selling!
Alternatively, you can join Facebook groups that specialize in buying and selling hockey cards, merch, and other sports memorabilia. This group is the perfect example and has over 9,000 members!
- Best For: In-person cash sales.
- Pros: Easy to sell cheaper hockey card collections.
- Cons: You likely have to negotiate prices and meet with them in person.
3. Alt
If you want a simple way to sell hockey cards for cash right from your smartphone, the new Alt app is for you.
With Alt, you can easily list your hockey cards for sale on its in-app marketplace for free. Alt also cross-lists your cards on eBay to find more buyers, and you only pay a 5% fee for sales.
The app also has a liquid auction option for high-value cards of $250 or more. This auction pays you automatically with a cash advance up to 60% of the value of your cards. So, if you need money by tomorrow, this could be your best bet.
I also like Alt since it has other neat features, like its collection tracker tool which lets you track and visualize the value of your cards and collection over time.
The app is completely free as well and is available on Android and iOS, so don’t be afraid to give it a try!
- Best For: Mobile selling and card management.
- Pros: Low seller fees and instant cash selling options.
- Cons: Hockey cards aren’t the most popular genre on Alt.
4. Beckett
With more than 127 million cards on its marketplace, Beckett is one of the best places to get cash for your hockey cards.
Complete with pricing guides and checklists, this card selling and trading platform makes it easy for every fan of hockey to geek out on beloved teams and players with merchandise.
You’re able to trade freely on the platform, but if you want to sell your hockey cards for cash, you need to register yourself as a dealer on Beckett. That being said, Beckett has its own grading service so it really covers all bases.
Monthly memberships cost $6.99, so it’s only worth signing up if you’re a more serious collector with authenticated card grades.
Once you register, you can see the most current price guides, sports card marketplace, and have access to numerous tools to help organize your collection and keep track of selling prices.
Basically, Beckett is a fantastic option to get cash for your hockey cards if you’re an experienced seller, or if you have a vast collection of vintage cards.
- Best For: Experienced dealers.
- Pros: Huge marketplace that attracts serious sellers.
- Cons: Need paid membership to sell, not suitable for beginners.
5. eBay
Another giant in the online trading and selling space is, of course, eBay.
Unsurprisingly, selling hockey cards, basketball cards, and other sports collectibles on this platform is incredibly simple which is why many legitimate collectors have been using eBay to sell hockey cards for years.
Although it doesn’t have its own pricing index or grading service like Beckett, you have complete control over your prices. The classic eBay auction feature can also help you secure the highest bid for your cards.
Now, I only suggest selling hockey cards on eBay that are professionally graded, since this is what many collectors are looking for. Alternatively, you can try selling entire hockey card collections of ungraded cards, but you might not earn much.
Uploading numerous high resolution photos and a thorough description of cards is also important. This helps you compete with more experienced dealers solidify yourself as a reputable seller.
If you’re new to eBay, you might not know that only your first 200 listings are free. After that, you pay $0.30 per listing as well as 5% commission for each sale.
If you’re looking to sell high quality or rare hockey cards on eBay, be aware that these costs could add up.
- Best For: Getting the highest price for your hockey cards.
- Pros: More value for your collection with eBay’s auction feature.
- Cons: You have to manage listings and shipping yourself.
6. Craigslist
If you have a mixed collection of hockey cards to sell, Craigslist could be the best option for you.
Craigslist is one of the most popular classifieds websites and Facebook Marketplace alternative out there. It’s a free and easy way to list items for local sale, including niche collectibles like hockey cards.
In my area, hockey card collections appear on Craigslist every now and then. And people sell hockey cards for cash with Craigslist all the time in larger cities.
Craigslist has the advantage of free listing, and the ability to meet in person for cash transactions, making it a very low-cost, risk-free way to sell hockey cards locally.
Our post on Craigslist versus Facebook Marketplace covers both of these local selling marketplaces in even more detail if you’re curious.
- Best For: Beginners or those who want to avoid platform fees.
- Pros: Huge marketplace that attracts many different kinds of collectors.
- Cons: Premiums may be lower as you’re using a more general platform and have to negotiate prices yourself.
7. Reddit r/hockeycardswap
While it might surprise you, another one of the best places to sell hockey cards is on Reddit’s community r/hockeycardswap.
Reddit has plenty of buy-and-sell groups for collectibles like Funko Pops, sports cards, Beanie Babies, and so many other niche items.
For r/hockeycardswap, there’s almost 2,000 active collectors in the community, and most of them are massive hockey fans, willing to geek out on every aspect of hockey card collecting.
Most days, there are multiple posts offering hockey cards available for purchase, allowing you to buy, sell, trade and swap, depending on your preferences.
Unlike some other Reddit threads, this community is specifically geared towards those looking to participate in transactions. Meaning that if you’d like to show off your collection or connect socially with other hockey card collectors, you’re better off using other subs like r/hockeycards.
This is a huge plus for this method of getting cash for your hockey cards, as you’re sure to only be contacted by serious buyers on this particular Reddit thread.
- Best For: Confident collectors who have been in the game for a while.
- Pros: Very specific marketplace that only attracts serious collectors.
- Cons: Need to manage negotiations, shipping, and payment yourself.
Extra Reading – How To Make Money On Reddit.
8. OfferUp
If you’re still wondering where to sell hockey cards, OfferUp is a great option to consider.
This free app lets you list just about anything for sale, including apparel, electronics, collectibles, shoes, and even vehicles.
Listing is also incredibly simple. All you have to do is take some photos of your hockey cards, set your price, write a description, and you’re off to the races.
Because OfferUp is a general marketplace, I’ve found it’s best for selling lower value collectibles that don’t fare well on premium marketplaces.
Also note that local selling is where OfferUp shines. You can sell online with the app, but there’s a hefty 12.9% service fee each time you make a sale.
Similar to Facebook Marketplace, you can negotiate with potential buyers on the app and organize to either ship your sold hockey cards off, or arrange a cash sale in-person.
- Best For: Selling more common hockey cards.
- Pros: Sales usually happen quickly.
- Cons: Online selling fees are expensive.
9. Otia
Otia is a premium market place that is perfect to sell valuable hockey card collections. It’s also an excellent option if you want to keep things hands-off.
To get started, you contact Otia with full details and photos of your inventory. Otia then offers a quote for your collection if it’s interested.
Otia generally wants to buy entire collections, so after accepting their offer, you ship all your hockey cards off and accept payment via cash, check, or PayPal.
If your collection is particularly extensive or valuable, Otia can also send its team to assist with transport instead of having to worry about appropriate packaging and the risks of posting.
And one of the best things about offloading your entire collection is that you don’t have to deal with rejected cards from individual buyers, which can happen on other platforms.
- Best For: Selling vintage hockey card collections.
- Pros: You can sell your whole collection at once.
- Cons: It’s a more niche and small marketplace.
10. Dave & Adam’s
One final place to sell hockey cards online you can consider is Dave & Adam’s.
This company has been one of the leaders in the collectibles industry for more than three decades and is a great option to sell higher value modern and vintage hockey cards.
Dave & Adam’s has a specific buy-list, so you can check whether or not they’re currently looking to purchase items from your collection. However, only hockey cards that are professionally graded or valued at $50 or more will be accepted.
It’s a pretty simple process to sell your hockey cards on. As soon as you’ve checked the buy list, all that’s needed is to submit your hockey card info to Dave & Adams, get approved for sale, and send your collection through UPS or Fedex.
Payment by either check, store credit, or PayPal cash occurs within 48 hours of your delivery, which is fantastic news if you’re wanting quick cash for your hockey cards.
- Best For: Fast sales of individual hockey cards or entire collections.
- Pros: Large buy list and quick payment.
- Cons: Lower price for your hockey cards than other options.
Extra Reading – What Can I Sell For $1,000?
Tips For Selling Hockey Cards For Cash
Now that you know some of the best places to sell hockey cards, here are some tips you can use to help increase the odds you make a sale:
- Do Your Homework: When selling hockey cards, make sure you research what similar cards are selling for so you price competitively.
- Cross-List Cards: One reason I like apps like Alt is that it lists your cards on its own marketplace plus eBay, so you access more potential buyers.
- Upload Several Photos: Upload several high-quality photos to give buyers confidence.
- Consider Grading: If you have rare or vintage hockey cards for sale, consider paying to have them graded with a grading service like Beckett Grading.
- Be Professional: Always respond to potential buyers quickly and professionally to increase the chances you make a sale.
This video from YouTuber and hockey card collector Albert also shares tips on how to grade your own cards and overall tips for how to sell hockey cards.
Extra Reading – The Best Places To Sell Pokemon Cards.
Final Thoughts
The world of collectible sports paraphernalia can be incredibly addictive. And if you’re interested in doing more buying, selling and trading, it’s possible to create a profitable side hustle for yourself.
Whether you’re interested in flipping hockey cards for a profit or simply want to better understand how rare and valuable your collection is, knowing your selling options both in person and online enables you to make informed selling decisions.
And if you stick with some of the best places to sell hockey cards listed above, you can find a wide buyer pool and safely sell your collection for cash.
Just make sure you understand any potential fees in the process before committing to a deal. Ensuring you’re fully aware of the timeframe for the transaction is also a good idea so you can plan when you can expect to get cash for your hockey cards.
Thanks for reading, and best of luck!
Want even more money-making ideas? Checkout:
