Where To Sell Football Cards For Cash – 10+ Best Options

Do you have binders full of football cards currently collecting dust in your garage or in storage somewhere?

If the answer is yes, you might be sitting on an excellent opportunity to get some quick cash.

People sell sports cards all the time, and American football cards are no exception. In fact, football cards have been popular since 1894. The first set of football cards featured players from Princeton and Yale, and this type of collectible sports card has grown in popularity ever since.

So, if you’re wondering where to sell football cards, you’re in luck!

This post is covering some of the best places to sell football cards so you can turn your card collection into cash.

Want more ways to make money besides selling your football cards? Checkout:

• EarnIn: Borrow up to $100 per day against an upcoming paycheck without paying membership fees!
• Best Match Auto: Save up to $600+ per year with this free car insurance quote tool!

Where To Sell Football Cards

If you’re selling football cards for the first time, the options can be overwhelming. After all, there are so many local selling sites and online marketplaces you can choose from.

But after selling things online for years, I’ve found some pretty reputable platforms for sellers. And there are also plenty of sites that specialize in buying and selling football cards that you can use.

1. eBay

With over 138 million buyers, eBay has been an online powerhouse and go-to location for selling football cards and other collectibles for over a decade.

It’s also one of the best places to sell football cards online since buyers are actively searching for cards to add to their collection. And when I searched on eBay, plenty of people were selling football cards, baseball cards, and other sports collectibles.

If you’re new to eBay, there are no listing fees on your first 200 postings. Once your cards sells, there’s a commission of 10%, up to a maximum of $750 for cards and collectibles.

As the seller, you need to arrange shipping unless the order is for a local eBay classifieds sale. Fortunately, eBay lets you charge buyers shipping fees for their orders, or you can add the cost into your listing.

Ultimately, eBay is one of the first places people should try selling football cards, or any niche collectible.

2. Alt

Need cash fast for your football cards? Alt offers quick ways to get money now for your collection. And it can even pay you up to 60% of the value of your football cards as a cash advance if you have the right cards.

I also like using Alt since it has an easy-to-use mobile app where you can manage, list, and sell your card collections. Plus, listing on Alt is free, and the platform crosslists to eBay to help you get sales faster.

You can also sell football cards in a fixed-price auction on Alt to buyers from around the world if you don’t need cash immediately. And you only pay a 5% seller fee for this service.

Alt even has some useful tools like a collection portfolio tracker where you can view the value of your entire collection.

Overall, it’s a modern, easy way to sell football cards and other valuable collector’s items right from your smartphone.

Try out Alt for free today!

3. Beckett

Beckett is a top sports card collectible site that specifically specializes in American football cards, basketball cards, baseball cards, and hockey cards.

It’s also one of the best places to sell football cards if you want to work with a site that specializes in buying and selling cards.

Just note that you have to have a pretty decent football card collection to sell with Becket.

That’s because you need to apply to become a registered Beckett Marketplace dealer, which costs $6.99 each month or $64.99 annually after their free 30-day trial.

Once you’re a dealer, you can list your collection for sale on Beckett’s Marketplace and begin negotiating with buyers from around the world.

👉 Start buying and selling with Beckett!

4. The Facebook Marketplace

Unsurprisingly, another popular place to sell football cards you can try out is the Facebook Marketplace.

This free and local classifieds site is a popular place for selling just about anything, ranging from furniture and watches to niche collectibles like football cards.

I’ve sold stuff on Facebook Marketplace before, and its main advantage is that it’s free and fast.

Creating a listing for your cards only takes a minute or two. Once it’s live, you can chat and negotiate with local buyers to agree on a price.

Plus, Facebook also has plenty of groups for sports card collectors, including several that are only for football cards. So, you can join these groups and post your collection for sale as well.

👉 12 Real Ways To Make Money Online.

5. Dave & Adam’s

Another reputable place to sell football cards for cash you can try out is Dave & Adam’s.

This popular online sports card marketplace specializes in rare cards and hobby boxes. Sellers submit cards for a quote, and you can sell  your football cards if you’re satisfied with the price Dave & Adam’s offers.

Getting an upfront quote is a selling point of Dave & Adam’s. Sellers pay for shipping unless it’s a massive sale, which is a small downside.

Additionally, Dave & Adam’s generally looks for graded football cards that are in good condition. So, a box of old and ungraded sports cards might not sell.

However, you don’t pay seller fees, and the process of selling football cards in bulk to Dave & Adam’s is probably easier than looking for several buyers yourself.

6. Reddit r/FootballCards

If you don’t mind dealing with independent buyers, another place to sell football cards you can try is Reddit’s r/footballcards.

This community of 120,000+ members provides a place for people to chat about, buy, swap, and sell football cards with other fans. It’s completely free to use, and there’s an official buy and sell thread where you can post your cards for sale.

This is a pretty unique way to make money using Reddit. But if you have some rare football cards, you might find plenty of buyers given the size of the community.

Just note you have to figure out shipping and a payment processing method that works for both parties.

7. OfferUp

If you’re still wondering how to sell football cards, one more option you can try is OfferUp.

This popular site to sell items locally can also help you sell cards nearby or nationwide. It’s similar to Facebook Marketplace, and you can list your cards for sale without paying any listing fees and then find local buyers.

OfferUp also has pre-approved meeting places that are in busy public areas to help improve safety. This is one of many reasons it’s such a popular local selling solution.

You can also sell football cards online with OfferUp. However, you pay an online service fee of $12.9% – or a $1.99 minimum when you ship an item.

For more OfferUp selling tips, check out my post on the top selling items on OfferUp for even more ideas of what to sell.

8. Craigslist

Another popular site to sell football cards locally or nationwide is Craigslist. Not only can you sell individual and local cards in your own area, you can also make sales around the country and ship as well.

Craigslist is also one of the best Facebook Marketplace alternatives since it’s free and easy to use. And when I searched my area, I found plenty of people selling football cards for cash and even buyers posting requests for cards.

The site is a bit old and clunky to use. But if you want a fast cash sale, it’s one of the easiest ways to sell football cards near you that you can ever use.

My post on Facebook Marketplace vs Craigslist compares these two marketplaces in even more detail if you want to learn more.

9. Sports Card Conventions

Sports card conventions can be a great way to sell individual football cards and sets. Many exhibitors at these shows are also buyers and may be interested in purchasing some of the cards you have to offer.

When selling football cards at sports card conventions, just keep in mind that you need to be competitive on your prices. After all, these card professionals need to make a profit when they resell the cards, so they need to be able to purchase at a fair price. 

Have a large amount of football cards to sell? In this case, it might be worth the time and investment to have your own booth at the convention.

Check with the show organizers for costs and figure out if it would make financial sense for you to set up your own tables.

10. Consignment Stores

One more place to sell football cards for cash is consignment stores.

While you may consign furniture, clothing, or household items, many consignment stores also consign collectibles and have a special section where they feature this type of merchandise.

When selling items at consignment stores, be aware that most of these specialty retailers take between 25% to 60% of the final sale price.

This is a steep price, but the trade-off is that you’re getting fast cash for your collection and don’t have to deal with buyers yourself.

However, alternatives like pawning for cash or hosting a local garage sale can also be effective solutions worth trying before turning to consignment stores.

11. COMC

Want somebody else to do the work when you sell your football cards? In this case, Check Out My Collectibles, also known as COMC, is a specialty retailer that focuses exclusively on sports cards.

An online consignment site for sports cards and memorabilia, COMC is an easy option when you are looking for the best place to sell football cards.

If COMC likes your football cards, it purchases from you directly, so you save the time and efforts you would have spent finding a buyer. 

Once you submit your cards, you get a quote. If you agree with the price, you send COMC the football cards to begin the selling process.

COMC does charge a couple of different fees for handling the sale of your football cards. There are consignment rates that vary depending on the speed of service that you choose, as well as seller fees that are a percentage of the sale. Refer to COMC’s selling rates for more details. 

12. Kruk Cards

One final place to sell football cards is Kruk Cards.

This marketplace has been buying and selling sports cards and other collectibles since 1987. And Kruk Cards can purchase your football cards directly and find buyers.

To sell football cards to Kruk Cards, you need to visit them or ship to their offices.

However, new cards aren’t always being accepted, so you will want to contact them first to see if they are accepting cards at this time.

Extra Reading – The Best Places To Sell Board Games.

Tips For Selling Football Cards For Cash

Now that you know some of the best places to sell football cards, I want to cover a few tips that I’ve found helpful whenever you try to sell or flip something for a profit:

• Do Your Homework: As you get ready to sell football cards or any collectible, take time and out what they’re actually worth. Online resources like Beckett Grading Services and eBay can give you an idea of the current market value for the cards that you have. 
• Get Your Cards Graded: If any of your football cards are particularly valuable, it might be worth the investment to have the cards graded by a professional grading service.
• Price Competitively: Like most collectibles and other items to sell online, you have to price fairly to make a sale. This is where doing market research can be a massive help to determine the going value of the cards that you have.
• Promote Your Cards: When selling items online, advertising helps. Whether you pay to boost your listing, share the items on social media, or find other ways to draw attention, spreading the word can help you find more buyers.
• Be Patient: Unless you sell the cards as a lot for a low price, it can take time to sell football cards. Do your research, be patient, and explore different opportunities to earn the most money from your sales.

This YouTube video from Football Card Quest also provides a step-by-step guide on how to sell football cards.

The video covers everything from grading and figuring out which cards are valuable to actually listing, so it’s a must-watch!

Extra Reading – Where To Sell Used Bikes For Cash.

Final Thoughts

I hope this guide on the best places to sell football cards helps you list your cards easily and get some cold hard cash for your collection.

It doesn’t matter if you’re selling a few cards to make a buck or want to start a flipping side hustle; choosing where to sell is incredibly important.

So, do your research, consider a few options, and then list your cards to start finding buyers.

Looking for more money-making ideas? Checkout:

• Where To Sell Funko Pops.
• The Best Places To Sell Sneakers.